Elektrine lite

← Feed

@vincentab@fosstodon.org

2026-10-24 12:00 UTC

@RossGayler@aus.social That's interesting! A bit ago I worked on something called "Data Analysis Decision Records", closely following the ADR that software engineers use. I even coded up an app an everything. But I tried to post it a few times and it never seem to quite catch on. It's too bad, because I think the idea has a lot of potential. Maybe I should invest in community building a bit. I'd be curious to know what you think! https://vincentarelbundock.github.io/dadr/

Replies (1)

  • @RossGayler@aus.social 2026-10-25 03:06

    @vincentab@fosstodon.org Thanks for sharing the link to dadrock - it looks interesting and I might try it next time I have some serious work to do. > I tried to post it a few times and it never seem to quite catch on. I was at the extreme end of documentation among my colleagues and, likewise, they weren't rushing to adopt my methods. > Maybe I should invest in community building a bit. I think that would be a good approach. The problem is that the systemic incentives for most people don't reward that level of rigour. I think a good target group for community development would be the reproducible-research/computational-reproducibility crowd. They are already intellectually committed to the idea of doing "extra" work to support reproducibility, so adding DADR might not seem like unrewarded extra work to them. In fact the existence of tooling to support it might make it *less* work over all if it also helps with other documentation they are already committed to. Getting the reproducibility people motivated would depend on convincing them that documentation of the reasoning behind choices is essential for reproducibility. (I have long been convinced that for scientific/engineering purposes the reasoning behind the decisions is probably *more* important than the actual decisions.) Having looked at your DADR roadmap, I suggest adding items relating to integrating DADR with reproducibility workflows. - On the purely mechanistic side, are there any additions that would ease the use of DADR with R/python notebooks, [targets] (https://books.ropensci.org/targets/)and the T orchestration language (https://tstats-project.org/)? - On the more conceptual side are there ways to structure notebooks, targets/t projects, and analytical projects to make it easier to apply DADR? #ReproducibleResearch #reproducibility #ComputationalReproducibility #ReproT #OpenScience

    Open ##5300353